Is the book really always better?

There is a natural urge to create adaptations with film. Film, after all, is still a relatively new art and audiences have not yet lost their childlike wonder at its ability to convey alternate realities so realistically and convincingly. Who hasn’t read a thrilling scene from one of their favorite books and thought “man, it would be awesome to see a movie version of this!” Yet, as everyone says, “the book is always better”.
While I don’t think that this is always true, it quite often is, and not always through any deficiency on the part of the director. Is this a problem inherent to filmed adaptations of the other arts? Are all adaptations doomed to “suffer in comparison”? (more…)




